
There’s a lot of reasons to make a movie but the primary ones are a.) to make money or b.) to express an idea. Depending on who the filmmakers are and what the situation around making it is the slider will fall closer to one side or the other. Still, there are times when a film will come out that doesn’t seem to really fall into either category as it is neither an obvious cash-grab product nor a deeply personal passion project that needs to be turned into an art piece. Sometimes the motivation for creating a film is so utterly unclear that it leaves you wondering who is this for and why was it made?
Williston tells the story of three employees of a Small-Cap oil company who travel to Williston North Dakota to try and close a deal to buy the last parcel of undeveloped land in the area from an owner (played by Mike Mushultubbe Simpson) who is notorious within the industry for his unwillingness to work with oil companies. Barb (Geneva Carr) and Larry (Matt Walsh) are long time employees and veterans of the industry who are joined by Tom (Jonathan Lipnicki) a neophyte accountant on his first business trip with the company. Despite the fact that even the smallest gas and oil companies have operating budgets in the hundreds of millions the three are forced to share a single room together where most of the “action” takes place. While this is weakly justified in the script it is clearly just a lazy plot device so that the deeply unpleasant Barb and walking HR nightmare Larry can have a more convenient way to manufacture conflict as they verbally (and even physically) abuse Tom.
Since this is a dramatic film, the inclusion of Matt Walsh as one of the principle cast is an interesting one as he is primarily known for his work not just as a legendary improv comedian but as one of the founding members of the UCB theaters which those familiar with the world of improv comedy will recognize as a tremendously big deal. I’ve personally been a huge fan of his since discovering him in the late ‘90s and since he has racked up nearly two hundred acting credits over the years including high profile projects like The Hangover and Veep I was genuinely baffled to see him fail to deliver a performance that was even remotely believable. While his stilted recitation of lines was the most egregious, Lipnicki and Carr fare only marginally better, the latter being the source of a lot of unintentional comedic moments with her over-the-top freak outs.

Billed as a thriller but most certainly not that, the film seems to struggle with its identity and purpose as it tackles a highly-charged, divisive subject matter without a willingness to commit to a particular point of view. It simply plods along, slowly and painfully, without trying to impart any kind of scathing commentary on an industry that is well known to be the single biggest contributor to the destruction of our planet. It doesn’t even try and take the route of Paramount Plus’ Land Man and act as thinly-veiled propaganda for the oil industry which, while not admirable, at least makes sense as to why it was created in the first place.
In Williston we simply follow three despicable characters who are presented as though they are gruff but empathetic despite the fact that their entire purpose is to coerce a Native American landowner, tastefully named (sigh) Indian Jim by writer/director Adam Seidel, into selling his property so it can be ravaged and bled dry. The fact that Barb has a third act crisis of conscious about the deal is not only unearned but thoroughly implausible for someone who has spent an entire career making these kinds of acquisitions. The fact that the oil company that they work for is smaller scale than the major ones doesn’t make the journey of three white folks trying to take and destroy even more land owned by native people any more compelling or sympathetic.
To be clear, there is nothing wrong with telling stories from the perspective of villainous characters, but the tone-deaf approach to the way this is portrayed is honestly baffling. Since the point doesn’t seem to be to comment on the oil industry but rather to delve into the friction caused by experienced workers who are set in their ways competing with the younger generation then maybe don’t pick an industry which is about as sympathetic as professional baby seal clubbers.

While this isn’t the first feature he has directed, Seidel is primarily known for being a playwright and Williston was based one of his original plays which is unsurprising given the restrictive location most of it takes place in and the somewhat stagy dialogue. Adapting any play into a compelling film is an uphill battle because, while being set in only a couple locations and relying almost entirely on dialogue to drive the narrative can work great in a live theater setting, it can feel claustrophobic and at odds with the show-don’t-tell nature of filmmaking. There has to be something very compelling about the characters and the story to overcome this obstacle and not only does this film not posses that but it seems to actively avoid exploring any kind of conflict that has the potential to take the story in an interesting direction. Bar fights, fist fights, drunk driving and even a hostage situation all pass so uneventfully without having any meaningful affect on the story that it seems like Seidel is actively opposed to anything that will take focus from the endless inane chatter between the characters.
The film is competently shot but that baseline achievement in no way makes up for an experience that provides no insight, no excitement, no humor, and with nothing relevant to say provides no reason as to why it should even exist or why anyone should ever watch it. This utter lack of meaningful content makes the viewing experience an unbearable slog and the scant eighty-two minute runtime feel longer than The Odyssey, but not nearly as entertaining.

Availability: Unavailable

The film premiered at the Coronado Island Film Festival on 11/7/26 but as of review no further release information has been provided.
